The Most Overrated Exercise in the Gym (and What to Do Instead)

Not every exercise earns its reputation.
Some are popular because they look intense — not because they build results.
They feed ego more than progress. 

Real training isn’t about what looks good on camera.
It’s about movement that delivers strength, control, and longevity.
Here’s what to stop wasting energy on — and what to replace it with.

The Barbell Upright Row

Looks serious. Feels powerful. Wrecks your shoulders.
This lift locks your joints into a position they were never built for, grinding down rotator cuffs over time. It might pump your traps, but it’s a fast track to impingement, not strength.

Do this instead: Dumbbell lateral raises and face pulls.
They hit the same muscles, protect your joints, and actually build balanced, functional shoulders.

Why it fails:

  • Restricted range of motion

  • Joint stress outweighs muscle benefit

  • Poor movement pattern disguised as intensity

Endless Sit-Ups for Abs

Hundreds of sit-ups won’t build a strong core — they’ll just tighten your hips and round your spine. The obsession with “feeling the burn” has replaced training for purpose.

Do this instead: Weighted planks, cable crunches, ab rollouts.
These teach your core to stabilise under pressure — real strength that transfers to every lift.

Stronger alternatives focus on:

  • Stability over flexion
  • Load control, not repetition
  • Transferable strength through the trunk

The Leg Press Obsession

It feels safe, controlled, heavy — but that’s the trap.
The leg press locks your movement, removes stabilisation, and inflates numbers without real-world carryover. Your legs might grow, but your overall strength won’t keep up.

Do this instead: Walking lunges, front squats, step-ups.
These train balance, coordination, and strength under real movement patterns.

Common mistakes:

  • Using ego weight for short range reps
  • Treating it like a squat replacement
  • Forgetting stability is strength

Smith Machine Squats

If it’s locked on a rail, it’s not a squat.
The Smith machine forces you into an unnatural line of movement that your body has to fight, not follow. It’s comfort disguised as effort.

Do this instead: Free-bar squats or Bulgarian split squats.
You’ll build balance, stability, and actual power — not just numbers that mean nothing off the track.

Cable Fluff Overload

Triple drop sets, half reps, and endless cable work might look productive — but most of it’s noise. You can’t out-pump bad programming.

Do this instead: Compound lifts.
Squats, deadlifts, presses, rows.
Master them. Log progress. Add intensity.
Simple. Effective. Brutal.

When in doubt:

  • Choose tension over tricks
  • Focus on control, not chaos
  • Log your lifts — and earn your numbers

Real Strength Doesn’t Need Hype

Your body doesn’t grow from trend-driven training — it grows from tension, recovery, and consistency.
Strength isn’t about who lifts the most plates or spends the longest in the gym.
It’s about the one who trains smart, with intent, and never wastes a rep.

Because in the end, real strength speaks for itself.

Back to blog